As my finance consulting practice is picking up steam, I'm having conversations with CFOs, heads of finance, founders, and CEOs. And what I'm noticing is that the same exact questions keep coming up.

There's a common thread. But within that commonality, there are also unique aspects to every company that mask it. Everyone is searching for Value-Added Finance, but we're calling it different things.

But first, a story.

Was I good at finance, or was I good at Allstate?

When I left Allstate (the first time), I was maybe 8 years into my career as a senior manager. I had a nagging question: was I good at finance, or was I just good at Allstate?

Anybody who's worked in a big company is going to understand exactly what I mean by that. Big companies are their own little corporate monsters. You only see parts of things, even in Sr Mgr roles. You can be liked and good at the specific thing you're doing, but that may not be the same as being good at finance.

So I had this nagging desire to understand: am I actually good at this thing? Am I better than average? Or am I just better than average because people tend to like me, and I show up, and I work hard?

So I left to go to a private equity-backed SaaS company that was about $50 million in ARR. And pretty quickly I found out that 80 to 90% of my skills transferred. But so did something else…

The same problems showed up

What surprised me was that the same problems showed up.

Finance leaders at the VP and CFO level had high expectations, and rightly so. They're the ones accountable for the numbers. When the answers weren't there, the natural move was to ask for more. More reporting. More analysis. More confidence before making the call.

What was usually missing wasn't effort or ambition. It was a clear strategy around analytics, forecast accuracy, reporting ecosystems, and what should be automated versus not. Without one, every ask becomes a top priority. Everything has to be automated. Everything has to be real time. Insights have to be instant. Forecasts have to be perfect.

That's a lot to ask of any finance team without a plan behind it.

The leaders who got what they wanted fastest were the ones willing to pause and diagnose the root cause behind the requests.

One root cause, a lot of downstream pain

I started to learn how to deconstruct that problem when I worked at Allstate. I would see that there was one root cause creating a lot of issues downstream, and those issues showed up in things like reporting, analysis, and forecasting.

Here's an example. When I was the senior manager of claims finance, claims costs were jumping up post-COVID, and it was hard for anyone to explain why. This was in 2021.

The natural reaction, from leadership and from my own team, was: we need more reporting, more analysis, more forecasting. And we spent hours on it. Late nights, long hours, so much anxiety, so much stress. But we never really made progress, because we hadn't correctly diagnosed the problem.

What it all traced back to was that the drivers of claims costs weren't called out correctly in our reporting, analysis, or forecast. They were called out in a mathematical way, not in a way that linked back to the business operations.

Once we got to that root cause - the lack of forecast/analysis drivers tied to how the business actually runs - leadership got exactly what they'd been asking for all along: answers they could act on. Not more, but better.

Everybody wants the same thing

Fast forward to today. I'm sitting on calls with CFOs, VPs, founders, CEOs, nonprofits, insurance companies. And they all keep saying the same thing:

  • "I want us to be more proactive."

  • "I want to know what good looks like."

  • "I want to know where to go next."

These are sharp leaders. They know finance can be doing more for the business. What they're missing isn't ability. It's a clear map for what to tackle first.

And this is my whole crux on value-added finance: find the key things holding finance back and move them forward.

Translate the tools into the outcome

Here's an example. On a call with a potential client recently, the conversation started with their tools. They'd invested in the data and the technology and wanted to get the most out of it.

What I did was translate the conversation into one outcome: speed to insight. "So what you really want is answers faster."

That's where the heads nodded.

And I said, "That's great. I need to assess your process, your people, and your technology in order to understand what really needs to happen here."

Speed to insight is really critical for senior leaders. And it's just one example. Others include:

  • Forecast accuracy

  • Reporting efficiency

  • Faster close

  • Stronger business partnerships

These are all outcomes. And we manage toward them using people, process, and the different technologies and tools embedded inside.

That's the common thread. Everybody wants the same thing. The work is figuring out which outcome matters most for your team, and then diagnosing what's actually standing in the way.

How we can help:

Have an outcome in mind that your team can't quite get over the line?

We help CFOs and finance leaders diagnose what's in the way and fix it in a systematic way. Hit reply to this email if that's something you need, or forward this to someone who might.

Brett Hampson, Founder of Forecasting Performance